Data & Insight

Dealers Demand Action

Srsly, IRS. Time to pay up.
No items found.

5 Minutes of Fresh Perspective

Reading the daily news doesn't have to suck. Get the email that will make you laugh and keep you informed...for free!
Dealers Demand Action

The clean vehicle tax credit program, designed to promote electric vehicle sales, is causing headaches for many of the dealers who have decided to participate. Dealers are struggling to get reimbursed for the advanced payments of Section 25E and Section 30D tax credits, leading to potential financial losses in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. 

Here’s what’s happening:

THE EV CREDIT STRUGGLE

Dealers are facing several crippling challenges to obtaining reimbursement for the advanced payment of Section 25E and Section 30D clean vehicle tax credits.

Firstly, dealers are experiencing problems with the registration process for the advance payment program. Another significant issue is the tight window for submitting the correct Time of Sale reports.

Additionally, there is confusion and concern among dealers about data security and correct reporting procedures, which has raised concerns about the privacy and security of sensitive information.

WHY IT MATTERS

This issue is significant because it impacts the financial stability of car dealerships across the country. Dealers have advanced these tax credits to consumers, but many have not been reimbursed, leading to potential losses in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. The problem could discourage dealer participation in the clean vehicle program, ultimately hindering efforts to promote EV sales and environmental sustainability.

THE DEALER RESPONSE

On May 30, 2024, the National Automobile Dealers Association formally requested relief from the U.S. Department of the Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service for dealers who have not been reimbursed for the advanced payment of Section 25E and Section 30D clean vehicle tax credits. These credits, applied at the point-of-sale for 2024 clean vehicle sales, have been held up due to issues with the registration and reporting processes in the Energy Credits Online portal.

CONCERNS AND DEMANDS

NADA’s letter, written by Senior Vice President of Regulatory Affairs Daniel E. Ingber, outlines a litany of difficulties dealers face in regards to verifying and obtaining these credits. Let’s break them down:

WHAT DO WE WANT?

  • Reimbursement Issues: Many dealers have not been reimbursed for the advanced payment of clean vehicle tax credits due to problems with registration and Time of Sale report submissions.
  • Technical and Administrative Problems: Dealers face frustrating issues on everything from registration statuses reverting to pending, being locked out of the portal, and the inability to amend reports.
  • Missed Deadlines: Due to those various problems, dealers are missing the 3-day deadline to file the Time of Sale report.
  • Financial Losses: Dealers are facing significant financial losses due to these issues, with aggregate losses potentially reaching hundreds of thousands of dollars.
  • Lack of Effective Support: Attempts to get assistance from the IRS help desk have been futile, with dealers receiving only insufficient and ineffective responses.

WHEN DO WE WANT IT?

  • Immediate Reimbursement: NADA is requesting immediate reimbursement for the affected dealers to prevent significant financial losses.
  • Technical Improvements: NADA acknowledges ongoing efforts to improve portal functionality but stresses the need for these improvements to be expedited and effective.
  • Dealer Participation Assurance: Dealers need assurance ASAP that the kinks are being worked out in order to minimize their risk and encourage continued participation in the program.
  • Prevent Double-Dipping: Address the concern of potential double-dipping by consumers, who could receive the credit both at the time of sale and when filing their tax returns.
  • Recognize Dealer Challenges: Accommodations should be made for dealers given the nascency of the advance payment program and the technical and administrative difficulties encountered.

Ingber says: "Given the nascency of the advance payment program and the corresponding technical and administrative difficulties encountered during the portal’s implementation, dealers should not be forced to incur this loss merely because they issued the wrong type of Time of Sale report, missed an arbitrary report submission deadline, or because their advance payment registration remained pending due to technological issues or a processing backlog impacting their registration."

MORE CONTEXT

The IRS launched IRS Energy Credits Online (IRS ECO) in November 2023 as a registration portal designed to streamline the process for sellers of new and previously owned clean vehicles eligible for the federal tax credits. This tool was intended to simplify and expedite the reimbursement process, promising advance payments within 72 hours of an accepted Time of Sale report. Surprising no one, this government-run program didn’t run quite as smoothly as expected.

MORE CONTINGENCIES

The Internal Revenue Service has highlighted several other caveats regarding the advance payments for clean vehicle tax credits. For example:

  • Cars and buyers must meet specific requirements. Including income limits and EV price thresholds. Buyers must sign an affidavit at dealerships affirming their income eligibility, with errors potentially requiring repayment of the tax break to the IRS.
  • Not all EVs or consumers qualify for the tax break. The Inflation Reduction Act's manufacturing requirements, aimed at boosting domestic production, limit which models are eligible. As of March 18, 2024, 36 new EV models qualify for tax breaks, including those from Acura, Audi, Cadillac, Chevrolet, Chrysler, Ford, Honda, Jeep, Lincoln, Nissan, Rivian, Tesla, and Volkswagen. Some models only qualify for half the tax credit ($3,750) instead of the full $7,500.
  • Not all car dealers are participating. Over 13,000 dealers have registered with the IRS Energy Credits Online portal, up from more than 11,000 in early February. For context, there were 16,839 franchised retail car dealers in the U.S. in early 2023, plus roughly 60,000 independent dealers, primarily selling used cars. Not all these dealers sell EVs.

TIGHT TIMELINE

For vehicles placed in service in 2024 or later, dealers must submit all reports through IRS Energy Credits Online within 3 calendar days of the date of sale. They must also provide the buyer with a copy of the accepted seller report submitted to IRS Energy Credits Online within 3 calendar days of the date of submission. This reporting ensures that buyers receive the tax credits they are entitled to, but the process has proven cumbersome for many dealers.

The tight 3-day window for submitting the correct Time of Sale reports exacerbates dealer stress. Those who miss this deadline due to technical glitches or misunderstandings are unable to claim the reimbursement, despite having advanced the credits to consumers. Additionally, the IRS ECO system, though secure and accurate, has proven challenging for some dealers to navigate, especially when issues arise unexpectedly.

ZOOM IN / ZOOM OUT

At the business level, dealers are experiencing financial strain and operational disruptions. 

At the consumer level, 90% of qualifying electric-vehicle buyers opt for a new clean vehicle tax credit as upfront payment

So from a broader perspective, these issues threaten the overall success of the clean vehicle tax credit program. If dealers pull out of the program, it will reduce consumer access and further slow the adoption of clean vehicles.

In addition, with all the complexities and difficulties, both buyers and sellers are rightfully worried that they’ll be SOL for the tax credit if something goes wrong, and everyone fears an audit that doesn’t go well. Ain’t nobody got time for that.

BEHIND THE SCENES

NADA has been in informal discussions with Treasury personnel, who have shown understanding but have yet to provide concrete solutions. While efforts are underway to enhance the portal's functionality, the timeline for these improvements is unclear. Dealers remain frustrated by the lack of real-time support and the inability to correct errors within the system promptly.

THE BOTTOM LINE

As Daniel E. Ingber said: “The significance of the problem cannot be overstated. Without imminent relief, dealers will incur significant financial losses and may cease participating in the program, which is detrimental to the overall goal of promoting clean vehicle sales.”

WHAT NOW?

As for dealers, here a few recommendations from the WI Automobile & Truck Dealers Association to be proactive in this situation:

  • Dealers should refrain from applying clean vehicle tax credits at the point-of-sale if they have not completed registration for the advance payment program or experience problems with the portal when submitting a Time of Sale report. 
  • For transactions involving a clean vehicle tax credit transfer, they should not deliver a vehicle to a customer until after properly submitting a Time of Sale report. 
  • Dealers are cautioned against spot deliveries involving a clean vehicle because a return after delivery could cause the vehicle to lose eligibility for a tax credit on a subsequent sale.

⭐️ Helpful links for even more information on Clean Vehicle Tax Credits:

Check out more!

Get the daily email that makes reading the news actually enjoyable. Stay informed and entertained, for free.